Green card marriages are not a realistic option

DESPERATE times call for desperate measures!  We have all heard this phrase many times in our lives. But the reality is that these desperate measures often produce disastrous results.  In the context of immigration law, the desperate act of marrying someone solely for a green card almost always ends very badly.
Marrying a person solely for a green card is often called a “green card marriage,” but the more official term used by the US Citizenship and Immigration Service (“USCIS”) is “sham marriage.”  It has been a plotline in multiple Hollywood movies and television shows over the years, including most recently in the primetime drama “On The Wings of Love.”
“On The Wings of Love” is a fictional story about a young Filipina who dreams of coming to the U.S. for a noble reason – to visit her mother’s gravesite.  After entering the US she is advised to get married to a US citizen so that she can be granted lawful permanent resident status (“green card”).  Before long there is a payment of $7,500 to a person willing to marry the Filipina.  The newlyweds are subsequently coached to stage fake photographs, pretend they are a couple, and even to memorize personal information about their spouse so that they can pass the required interview.
Though “On The Wings of Love” is a fictional television show, this scenario too often is played out in real life because many people mistakenly believe that marrying a US citizen is an easy way to obtain a green card.  The USCIS is well aware that many people are willing to marry a person for the sole purpose of obtaining a green card.  For this reason, they dedicate a substantial amount of resources towards detecting these “sham marriages.”  Because of the USCIS’ efforts, it is crucial that a person applying for a green card on the basis of their marriage understand what the USCIS considers to be a valid marriage for immigration purposes.
First, the immigrant and their US citizen spouse must prove that their marriage is “bonafide.”  This is not an easy task because the USCIS officers are highly trained to detect sham marriages.  And remember, the USCIS does not have to prove that the marriage is a sham.
The immigrant and their US citizen spouse must show that they “intended to establish a life together” at the time they entered into their marriage.  Oral statements of the immigrant and their US citizen spouse are not sufficient, and neither are written statements of friends and family members.  On the contrary, the USCIS will also want to closely examine the conduct of the parties, e.g., is the couple residing together, how long have they known each other, are they conducting themselves as husband and wife, etc.  The USCIS will also consider whether the parties have a sufficient amount of documentation proving the bonafides of their marriage.
The USCIS will also commonly want to ask the immigrant and their US citizen spouse personal questions about their relationship.  The potential questions a person may be asked are nearly limitless, as the USCIS may ask just about anything they believe a person should know about their spouse.  While you can try and learn as much as possible about your spouse, it is virtually impossible to learn enough about another person if you are not really married to them.  Sure you can learn your spouse’s date-of-birth or name of their employer, but how do you expect to know about your spouse’s eating habits unless you actually live together? How are you going to know about your significant other’s daily routine unless you are married?
Another issue that sometimes comes up is what happens if the US citizen spouse dies or physically or emotionally harms the immigrant.  Despite the breakdown of the marriage, the immigrant may still be eligible to apply for their green card.  However, they will still have to prove that the relationship was bonafide at the time of the inception of the marriage.
The risks of entering into a “sham marriage” are substantial.  Fines, jail time, but no green card.  In fact, the person being petitioned will be barred from ever being petitioned again as an immigrant, even if the subsequent relationship is bonafide.  We all understand that sometimes you may think a “green card marriage” is the only option, but an experienced and knowledgeable immigration attorney will advise you against following this illegal, and almost sure-to-fail path, despite what you may see on television or in the movies.


Atty. Reeves has represented clients in numerous landmark immigration cases that have set new policies regarding INS action and immigrants’ rights. His offices are located in Pasadena, Irvine, San Francisco, Las Vegas and Makati City. 
Telephone: (800) 795-8009 


The analysis and suggestions offered in this column do not create a lawyer-client relationship and are not a substitute for the personalized representation that is essential to every case. 

Atty. Reeves Miller Zhang & Diza
Atty. Reeves Miller Zhang & Diza

Reeves Miller Zhang & Diza (RMZD) was founded in 1980 with the goal of providing superior legal services to the immigrant community. Throughout the past 37 years we have been devoted exclusively to the practice of U.S. immigration and nationality law. Our immigration attorneys and dedicated support personnel work tirelessly to provide effective legal representation to individuals and businesses regarding visas, permanent resident status, U.S. citizenship, and relief from deportation. We are known for our extraordinary commitment to clients, as we provide each client with the personal attention they deserve. At RMZD, we have a diverse clientele that includes individuals, family-owned business, and major international corporations. We are able to assist our clients with all of their immigration needs, regardless of whether it is as simple as renewing a green card or as complex as having a foreign employee transferred to the U.S. to continue their employment with an international company’s U.S. office.

No Comments Yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.